Nino Tatoshvili, criminal defence lawyer in Georgia
Medical & reproductive criminal law

Coercion, Exploitation and Trafficking Red Flags

Coercion, exploitation and trafficking red flags in healthcare or reproductive matters: preserve consent, communications, movement and control records.

English legal guideTbilisi · Georgia-wide
What matters in this case

The legal and evidential questions

Coercion, Exploitation and Trafficking Red Flags. The first task is to identify the alleged criminal conduct rather than treating every adverse outcome as a crime. The statutory starting point shown on this page is Article 150 (Coercion). It focuses on an unlawful physical or mental restriction of a person's freedom to act or refrain from acting.

Preserve consent and intake versions, communications, travel or accommodation arrangements, control of documents or money, movement records, clinical files and each participant’s role.

Questions to answer first

01

Identify the alleged criminal conduct rather than treating every adverse outcome as a crime

02

Preserve complete clinical, consent, laboratory, payment and communication records

03

Separate individual practitioner, clinic, agency and management roles

04

Coordinate medical expertise with criminal procedure and any civil or regulatory case

Evidence that may matter

  • Complete medical and consent records
  • Clinical protocols and professional standards
  • Laboratory, embryo or gamete records
  • Contracts, invoices, transfers and agency communications
  • Independent medical, genetic and forensic expertise
Criminal Code articles to consider

Criminal Code articles to check

Article 143¹

Human trafficking

Potentially relevant where recruitment, transport, harbouring or receipt is linked to exploitation through prohibited means; victim protection is essential.

Read full Article 143¹ text on this page
Why the cited article can change
Relevant Criminal Code wording

Read the relevant Criminal Code provisions

The panel below reproduces the available official English wording for convenient reading. Check the current Georgian text and the exact article part before relying on it, because later amendments may not yet appear in translation.

Article 150Coercion

1. Illegal restriction of a person’s freedom to act, i.e. coercing him/her physically or mentally to perform or not to perform an action, performance of or abstaining from performance of which is his/her right, or to make him/her experience an influence against his/her own will, –

shall be punished by a fine, or corrective labour for a term of up to one year or house arrest for a term of six months to two years, or imprisonment for a term of up to one year, with or without restriction of the rights regarding weapons.

2. The same act committed:

a) knowingly by an offender against a minor, a person in a helpless condition, a person with disability or a pregnant woman;

b) by a group of persons;

c) repeatedly, –

shall be punished by corrective labour for a term of up to two years, or imprisonment for a term of up to eighteen months, with or without restriction of the rights regarding weapons.

The consolidated official source is listed in the source section at the end of this guide.

Article 143¹Human trafficking

1. Purchase or sale of human beings, or any unlawful transactions in relation to them, by means of threat, use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, blackmail, fraud, deception, by abuse of a position of vulnerability or power or by means of giving or receiving of payment or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, as well as recruitment, carriage, concealing, hiring, transporting, providing, harbouring or receiving of a human being for exploitation, –

shall be punished by imprisonment for a term of seven to twelve years, with deprivation of the right to hold an office or to carry out activities for up to three years.

2. The same act committed:

a) by the offender knowingly to a pregnant woman;

b) knowingly by the offender against a helpless person or a person who financially or otherwise depends on the offender;

c) by abusing the official position, –

shall be punished by imprisonment for a term of nine to fourteen years, with deprivation of the right to hold an office or to carry out activities for up to three years.

3. The same act committed:

a) repeatedly;

b) against two or more persons;

c) by taking the victim abroad;

d) using violence or threat of violence which is dangerous for life or health;

e) by a group of persons with preliminary agreement, –

shall be punished by imprisonment for a term of 12 to 15 years, with deprivation of the right to hold an office or to carry out activities for up to three years.

4. The act provided for in paragraphs 1, 2 or 3 of this article:

a) committed by an organised group;

b) that caused the death of the victim or resulted in other grave consequences, –

shall be punished by imprisonment for a term of 15 to 20 years, with deprivation of the right to hold an office or to carry out activities for up to three years.

Note:

1. For the purposes of this article and Article 1432 of this Code, the following shall constitute exploitation for the purpose of gaining material or other benefit:

a) inducing a person to perform labour or other services;

b) inducing a person to provide sexual services;

c) engaging a person in criminal activities, prostitution, pornographic or other anti-social activities;

d) removing, transplanting or otherwise using an organ, part of an organ or tissue of the human body by force or deception;

e) subjecting a human being to practices similar to slavery or to modern-day slavery. Subjecting a human being to modern-day slavery shall mean creation of such conditions when the person performs certain work or renders services in favour of another person in return for payment, inadequate payment or without payment, and he/she is not able to change these circumstances because of his/her dependence on that person. Dependence on a person may be caused by, among other things:

e.a) confiscation, control or intentional unlawful handling of personal identification documents;

e.b) restriction of the right to free movement or control of free movement;

e.c) restriction or control of communication (including correspondence and phone calls) with family members or other persons;

e.d) creation of coercive or threatening environment.

2. For the purposes of this article and Article 1432 of this Code, it does not matter whether a person consents to his/her pre-determined exploitation.

3. For the acts provided for by this article, a legal person shall be punished by deprivation of the right to carry out activities or by liquidation and a fine.

The consolidated official source is listed in the source section at the end of this guide.

How the process may develop

01Clinical and procedural triage
02Record preservation
03Consent and role analysis
04Independent expert review
05Police or prosecutor response
06Parallel regulatory and civil coordination
Sources & legislation

Primary sources for this guide

Before acting, compare this guide with the current Georgian text and the exact document served in the case. The official English translation may not include the latest amendment.

Criminal Code of GeorgiaLaw on Health CareLaw on Patient Rights
Need advice on this issue?

Discuss the facts, documents and next decision.

Use the urgent route for detention, searches, questioning or time-critical international matters. Standard and corporate enquiries can be scheduled separately.

Urgent assistance →